Ao I've finally decided to hop on the BoS bandwagon and one thing I've noticed when looking at the top logs is that many of them are using Mark of the Claw as their neck enchant rather than Mark of the Hidden Satyr. When simming it for myself, however, Mark of the Hidden Satyr simmed higher, although it may be within the realm of error since the difference wasn't that much. Icy Veins currently recommends Mark of the Hidden Satyr in its guide, but I was wondering if I could get more insight onto why that is and why many top logs are using Mark of the Claw instead.

Could someone give me the best advice regarding heirlooms and enchants?
question one: I'm going to make a Holy Paladine (first time)
therefore the stat priority is: 
Intellect; Critical Strike; Mastery; Haste; Multistrike; Versatility question two: Heirlooms to pick are: 
 
Pristine Lightforge Helm
Pristine Lightforge Spaulders
Pristine Lightforge Breastplate
Pristine Lightforge Legplates
Eternal Horizon Choker  or  Eternal Amulet of the Redeemed  or  Eternal Talisman of Evasion  (please advise)
Ancient Bloodmoon Cloak 1
Discerning Eye of the Beast
Swift Hand of Justice
Weathered Observer's Shield  or  Musty Tome of the Lost
Devout Aurastone Hammer with either the above
Question three:
 Do I enchant all with 
Gift of Critical Strike
or put 
Gift of Mastery
on those with critical strike already in the stat?
 
Looking forward to this. If you could explain your suggestions it would also be a great help. Thank you

whats up with the changes, one minute it stack mastery then its stack multi. Then its back to master and now back to multi. Just who do we listen to??? please help this ol guardian :)

dear,
wondering what enchant is better for weapon if you can't get jade one yet? is it elemental force of windsong? It's for a fire mage
greetz