Windwalker seeking theoretical trinket help

[andyhre 0]

Hello Windwalker community.  I've recently had the good fortune of getting three brand new trinkets more or less on the same weekend and wanted to get a sense of which you'd use.  This is my character (https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-us/character/scarlet-crusade/gordoorso) and as of this posting two of the three trinkets are being worn (though the socket isn't correct as it is listed).

Anyway, the three trinkets are:

925 version of Engine of Eradication [this seems the obvious keeper of the bunch] (http://www.wowhead.com/item=147015/engine-of-eradication&bonus=3561:1482)

915 version of Infernal Cinders (http://www.wowhead.com/item=147009/infernal-cinders&bonus=3561:1482)

910 version of Spectre of Betrayal (http://www.wowhead.com/item=151190/specter-of-betrayal&bonus=3561:1492)

The ilvl on the latter two isn't such a big difference, but my concern is that the swap from Agility on the Spectre to Crit on the Cinders, even if the proc on the cinders seems more useful than the clicky on the Spectre.  I know parsing is always the best choice, but I also value the wisdom of the community.  If you have thoughts as to how you'd expect these to differ, I'd appreciate.

Thanks, 

 

Gordoorso the Clumsy of Scarlet Crusade

(No, it's not my real title but it should be)

 

[Orthios 271]

I suggest looking at Babylonius's Trinket spreadsheet, which gives a decent breakdown of how trinkets stack up against one-another.  According to it, Specter of Betrayal is a very powerful trinket for Single Target and a decently powerful trinket for AoE while the Infernal Cinders trinket isn't quite as good.

[andyhre 0]

tyvm.  I didn't know about this tool, but now I will experiment.  Thanks!