Ghuerilla 2 Report post Posted February 28, 2015 Could we get an opening BM rotation using Dire Beast since it is best on Gruul? The current opener assumes SF. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Msa 1 Report post Posted February 28, 2015 Could we get an opening BM rotation using Dire Beast since it is best on Gruul? The current opener assumes SF. From where do you get that Dire Beast is better than stampede on Gruul? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Orthios 271 Report post Posted February 28, 2015 From where do you get that Dire Beast is better than stampede on Gruul? Wrong talent tiers. Dire Beast is on the same tier as Steady Focus and TotH. Could we get an opening BM rotation using Dire Beast since it is best on Gruul? The current opener assumes SF. Your opener should look like this: Pre-pot > Stampede + Racials + On-Uses (all on pull) > DB > BW > KC > Barrage > Proceed. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Msa 1 Report post Posted February 28, 2015 Wrong talent tiers. Dire Beast is on the same tier as Steady Focus and TotH. Your opener should look like this: Pre-pot > Stampede + Racials + On-Uses (all on pull) > DB > BW > KC > Barrage > Proceed. lol, I meant Steady Focus :) Thx Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Ghuerilla 2 Report post Posted March 3, 2015 Thank you! Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
zvr 0 Report post Posted March 7, 2015 (edited) Hello, I have small problem. Recently I had an argument with another hunter in my guild about Focus Fire usage. Right now I'm using WeakAura that is recommenced in Azor's guide, and according to it FF is always used together with BW at any stacks, or at 5 stacks when not under BW buff. My guildie says, that it's totally wrong and FF should be used AFTER Bestial Wrath, because "under BW your pet does more damage with full Frenzy stacks and this is why you shouldn't consume it with FF, so use it after BW expiration". I'm a noob with BM and I'm still learning to master this spec with help of Azor's guide, but just to be sure I would like someone to clarify information I wrote. Edited March 7, 2015 by zvr Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 7, 2015 Hello, I have small problem. Recently I had an argument with another hunter in my guild about Focus Fire usage. Right now I'm using WeakAura that is recommenced in Azor's guide, and according to it FF is always used together with BW at any stacks, or at 5 stacks when not under BW buff. My guildie says, that it's totally wrong and FF should be used AFTER Bestial Wrath, because "under BW your pet does more damage with full Frenzy stacks and this is why you shouldn't consume it with FF, so use it after BW expiration". I'm a noob with BM and I'm still learning to master this spec with help of Azor's guide, but just to be sure I would like someone to clarify information I wrote. Tell your friend to (kindly) stick it and/or read tooltips. http://www.wowhead.com/spell=19623/frenzy- 4% increased ATTACK SPEED * 5 is 20% ATTACK SPEED at 5 stacks. http://www.wowhead.com/spell=82692/focus-fire- 6% increased HASTE (same effect as attack speed PLUS focus regen to pet PLUS focus regen to hunter PLUS instant focus surge to pet) * 5 is 30% HASTE at 5 stacks PLUS 8% * 5 ATTACK POWER = 40% attack power and 30% haste. Ask your friend in a gentle fashion why he'd rather have 20% attack speed rather than 30% haste and 40% attack power. 1 Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Orthios 271 Report post Posted March 8, 2015 So, question is: now that CS > KC/FF > CS has been nerfed, what would the optimal opener be (and would this maybe affect talent choices)? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 8, 2015 Won't affect talent choices in the slightest. Sims didn't even model the "bugged" behaviour before, so it was always a tiny bit better in real life than in the sims, but nothing changes decision-making wise. The new opener is in the guide. Do discuss, though. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Valtix 0 Report post Posted March 8, 2015 For the opener, I notice Azortharion says "use FF as soon as it becomes available." Does this mean during the opener we use FF as soon as we get one frenzy stack? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 8, 2015 That is what it means, since you pop Stampede immediately and one is supposed to expend any amount of Frenzy stacks when Stampede is up. This is mentioned elsewhere in the guide but people don't make the connection by themselves unless they use my WeakAura so I made it clear there. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Niix 169 Report post Posted March 8, 2015 I'd be curious to see the benefit in practice of waiting to use our first double cobra until after bw is over. Isn't the regen inside of bw kinda wasted anyways? I suppose it gives your pet focus regen right? I'll toy around with it later but I'm curious to know the different openers you tried and how they compare with one another. I've never been one to mess around with openers on simc so i'm not entirely sure how one would even do that. However thinking about it, if you haven't already done it that is, would be curious to see how this opener compares to your double cobra opener. Stampede BW + On Uses + KC Barrage Arcane Arcane Arcane Kill Command Arcane Arcane Cobra Cobra Kill Command I'm not even home at the moment and I'm somewhat tired so my thinking is likely incorrect but i'd just be curious to see the actual loss in DPS from waiting to get steady focus until after the real meat of your focus spending is over. because in reality the double cobra opener 1. generates no focus, and is only really there to get the steady focus buff up quickly. however it seems odd, because we don't spend enough focus from the cap in BW to really require the steady focus during the opener, no? 2. possibly wasting 3 seconds of MDT in the opener outside of BW seems counter-intuitive. I feel like I could be wrong in the sense that i can't remember if steady focus does anything for our pet other than increased Focus Regen, or frankly if it even does that. i haven't played BM since the early days of ToT so the way some of our spells interact with our pet are fairly lost on me. just stirring up possible discussion anyways. cheers. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 I'd be curious to see the benefit in practice of waiting to use our first double cobra until after bw is over. Isn't the regen inside of bw kinda wasted anyways? I suppose it gives your pet focus regen right? I'll toy around with it later but I'm curious to know the different openers you tried and how they compare with one another. I've never been one to mess around with openers on simc so i'm not entirely sure how one would even do that. However thinking about it, if you haven't already done it that is, would be curious to see how this opener compares to your double cobra opener. Stampede BW + On Uses + KC Barrage Arcane Arcane Arcane Kill Command Arcane Arcane Cobra Cobra Kill Command I'm not even home at the moment and I'm somewhat tired so my thinking is likely incorrect but i'd just be curious to see the actual loss in DPS from waiting to get steady focus until after the real meat of your focus spending is over. because in reality the double cobra opener 1. generates no focus, and is only really there to get the steady focus buff up quickly. however it seems odd, because we don't spend enough focus from the cap in BW to really require the steady focus during the opener, no? 2. possibly wasting 3 seconds of MDT in the opener outside of BW seems counter-intuitive. I feel like I could be wrong in the sense that i can't remember if steady focus does anything for our pet other than increased Focus Regen, or frankly if it even does that. i haven't played BM since the early days of ToT so the way some of our spells interact with our pet are fairly lost on me. just stirring up possible discussion anyways. cheers. 1) 50% focus regen is way more focus returned than what you -don't- get casting those Cobras. The focus is not for us, it is for the pet, and the pet can -always- use more focus, even if it gets its Basic off on cooldown, because of the Wild Hunt mechanic making 50+ focus Basics do double damage. 2) What would you rather have, a trinket proc with the main value being pet focus regen.. Or Steady Focus, the main value being pet focus regen? Specifically, 50% focus regen vs however much the 2k-or-so haste is gonna give you - about 20%? Problems with your opener: 1) On a multitude of fights, Stampede will lose attacks due to repositioning. Especially Blackhand Mythic, but it's no non-issue on Hans&Franz, Beastlord Darmac, Blast Furnace depending on what you open on, Iron Maidens, Operator Thogar.. 2) There's a pretty real chance that your first KC will be un-trinketed, as will your first couple of attacks within that strong BW, same with Barrage which is our highest DPE ability outside genuine cooldowns. 3) You are gonna have to do the dual-Cobras eventually. Any lost uptime in the opener (and noting that Haste scales multiplicatively, and Bloodlust will likely be up) is a lot of wasted pet focus when you combine Haste from Bloodlust, potentially troll racial and the fact that you'll cash in 6% haste very early from Focus Fire. The main counter-argument to my method is "why not just Arcane Shot, instead"? An Arcane Shot is a bit under twice the DPE of a pet basic. Okay, so, how many Arcanes do we lose with the method, for the entirety of the fight? Well, base hunter regen is 5 focus/sec, Bloodlust + Haste buff puts that to 5.82 (such scaling), at least with my shitty levels of Haste because Mastery build (594 rating). Precast Cobra loses you 14 focus but no regen since you wouldn't have regenned anything anyway it being a precast. Next Cobra loses you 14 focus + ~1.75s of 5.82/s focus regen assuming Hero wasn't popped RIGHT on pull this is about 24.2 focus. Or just 24 focus, so barely an Arcane Shot's worth of focus is actually lost. I vaguely recall hunter pets regenning at a higher rate, but Wowpedia says they do at 5f/s baseline too, do the same calc. By not getting Steady Focus up early, and only doing it after ~13 seconds if we use your opener as a baseline for this, that's 5.82f * 13 = 75,66 (76) focus lost from the pet, that's 3 Basic Attacks completely LOST, effectively, or about 12k * 3 = 36k damage whereas by doing the precasting stuff we lost 1 Arcane Shot of about 20k damage. Since that Arcane Shot would've landed within BW, we can add 2k damage to the loss to make it 22k, there, but the Basic Attacks get 20% more damage, meaning we're talking 14.4k * 3 damage lost from not getting the Basic Attacks instead, or 43.2k damage. So we can conclude that the difference barely exists. There's probably some more micro-adjustment that could be made, such as you losing 1.8s of pot uptime, effectively. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Niix 169 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 1) 50% focus regen is way more focus returned than what you -don't- get casting those Cobras. The focus is not for us, it is for the pet, and the pet can -always- use more focus, even if it gets its Basic off on cooldown, because of the Wild Hunt mechanic making 50+ focus Basics do double damage. 2) What would you rather have, a trinket proc with the main value being pet focus regen.. Or Steady Focus, the main value being pet focus regen? Specifically, 50% focus regen vs however much the 2k-or-so haste is gonna give you - about 20%? Problems with your opener: 1) On a multitude of fights, Stampede will lose attacks due to repositioning. Especially Blackhand Mythic, but it's no non-issue on Hans&Franz, Beastlord Darmac, Blast Furnace depending on what you open on, Iron Maidens, Operator Thogar.. 2) There's a pretty real chance that your first KC will be un-trinketed, as will your first couple of attacks within that strong BW, same with Barrage which is our highest DPE ability outside genuine cooldowns. 3) You are gonna have to do the dual-Cobras eventually. Any lost uptime in the opener (and noting that Haste scales multiplicatively, and Bloodlust will likely be up) is a lot of wasted pet focus when you combine Haste from Bloodlust, potentially troll racial and the fact that you'll cash in 6% haste very early from Focus Fire. The main counter-argument to my method is "why not just Arcane Shot, instead"? An Arcane Shot is a bit under twice the DPE of a pet basic. Okay, so, how many Arcanes do we lose with the method, for the entirety of the fight? Well, base hunter regen is 5 focus/sec, Bloodlust + Haste buff puts that to 5.82 (such scaling), at least with my shitty levels of Haste because Mastery build (594 rating). Precast Cobra loses you 14 focus but no regen since you wouldn't have regenned anything anyway it being a precast. Next Cobra loses you 14 focus + ~1.75s of 5.82/s focus regen assuming Hero wasn't popped RIGHT on pull this is about 24.2 focus. Or just 24 focus, so barely an Arcane Shot's worth of focus is actually lost. I vaguely recall hunter pets regenning at a higher rate, but Wowpedia says they do at 5f/s baseline too, do the same calc. By not getting Steady Focus up early, and only doing it after ~13 seconds if we use your opener as a baseline for this, that's 5.82f * 13 = 75,66 (76) focus lost from the pet, that's 3 Basic Attacks completely LOST, effectively, or about 12k * 3 = 36k damage whereas by doing the precasting stuff we lost 1 Arcane Shot of about 20k damage. Since that Arcane Shot would've landed within BW, we can add 2k damage to the loss to make it 22k, there, but the Basic Attacks get 20% more damage, meaning we're talking 14.4k * 3 damage lost from not getting the Basic Attacks instead, or 43.2k damage. So we can conclude that the difference barely exists. There's probably some more micro-adjustment that could be made, such as you losing 1.8s of pot uptime, effectively. Interesting points. I didn't take into account the 50+ basic dealing extra damage. That is very huge. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 It is great because it means that there is no real point of DR for pet focus regen. 'Excess' just becomes more damage. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Orthios 271 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 First off, base focus regen is 4 focus per second. Second, Cobra Shot will always regenerate 22 focus, 14 from the ability, and then 8 from (4*(1+Haste)*(2/(1+Haste)) - or, 4*2=8 since the 1+haste factor cancels out, unless you have steady focus up, in which case the 4 base becomes 6 and you get 12 from the cast time. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 Doesn't matter since both methods spend no focus in the opener anyway meaning that cast/passive regen is 0 for both situations since the idea was to compare the openers. His uses a free Stampede, mine does a Cobra. Regen is 0 in either case so honestly it might not make sense to even include the direct regen from Cobra in the comparison but it's 4 am soon and I'm tired. Fair on the focus regen base though, although it didn't end up being relevant because I checked the 5.82 in game. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
zvr 0 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 Everyone is talking about BM now, but I have one question about SV :) Some time ago I've read here that for single target fights it was good to spam Arcane Shot instead of wasting focus on Glaive Toss or Barrage. Is this option still viable? Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Niix 169 Report post Posted March 9, 2015 Everyone is talking about BM now, but I have one question about SV Some time ago I've read here that for single target fights it was good to spam Arcane Shot instead of wasting focus on Glaive Toss or Barrage. Is this option still viable? Glaive Toss on Single, Barrage on >1. ARcane Shot spam can be good without any set bonuses if you get a MS proc, as far as I remember. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Orthios 271 Report post Posted March 10, 2015 So, Bracers of Callous Disregard is still missing from the BiS list, and considering that it's haste/mastery, I'd say it's BiS for BM. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
f0nZi3 7 Report post Posted March 11, 2015 So, Bracers of Callous Disregard is still missing from the BiS list, and considering that it's haste/mastery, I'd say it's BiS for BM. It's listed as "Trash Drop" on the main page, but you are right... it's missing from the "BRF BM" tab. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Azortharion 60 Report post Posted March 11, 2015 Not listed because it is worse because of lower stat budget, my spreadsheet-gnome tells me. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Orthios 271 Report post Posted March 11, 2015 Well, that makes sense. Though why they have a lower stat budget is beyond me, when the trash boots have the same budget as the rest of the boots. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
rtfhnrfthn 0 Report post Posted March 11, 2015 (edited) Hi Hunter bro, I'm using Azor guide, and then the Gear calculator in order to calculate the best item. But, the new version can't be save ? i mean i can't make a copy to put the stats and to calculate, Is it me or the owner of the doc disable it ? Thanks (sorry for my english, not native) Edit : talking about that : https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1njDdB3WUA5vsZcGhlf2W0HYpQ1KBde6ThFeCwntiVtk/htmlview?pli=1&sle=true# Edited March 12, 2015 by Raveroo Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Selessys 0 Report post Posted March 13, 2015 (edited) I have a question wich trinket combination is better for BM hunter Beating Heart of the Mountain(heroic) + Captive Micro-Aberration(mythic OR Beating Heart of the Mountain(heroic) + Humming Blackiron Trigger(Normal Warforged) Thanks for advice Edited March 13, 2015 by Selessys Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites